The Armstrong Research Group
Applications of Chemical Biology to future energy technologies. Protein film electrochemistry and other physical techniques for studying and exploiting metalloenzymes. Enzymes as electrocatalysts. The chemical basis of hydrogenases and biohydrogen. Enzymes and nanoparticles. Enzyme-based Fuel Cells. Reversible electrocatalysis of CO2 activation. The Electrochemical Leaf for Enzyme-catalysed Organic Synthesis.
Enzymes as reversible electrocatalysts
|The aim of this research is to establish fundamental chemical insight for underpinning future renewable energy technologies – an area of intense innovation that is now at the forefront of international science. Capturing the Sun’s energy as a storable chemical (fuel) is a familiar characteristic of biology and we are building on the chemistry that is involved, exploring new avenues and inventing technologies based on enzymes. Enzymes are the most efficient electrocatalysts and a wonderful inspiration for us in terms of what is possible! Enzymes can convert interconvert H2, O2 and water with the highest rates and minimum of energy waste, they can activate CO2 – producing CO or formate for fuel and for organic chemistry, with just a tiny overpotential. The need to optimise efficiency as well as rates, when considering how an organism uses the limited energy available to it, has driven the evolution of ‘near perfect’ enzymes. We are using a suite of novel electrochemical techniques called protein film electrochemistry (PFE), developed in Oxford, to study how enzymes such as hydrogenases (Fe,Ni), blue Cu oxidases (Cu), carbon-monoxide dehydrogenases (Fe,Ni), and NAD(P)H recycling enzymes (flavin) important for biotechnology, achieve rates that are orders of magnitude higher than conventional catalysts, and do this without requiring a large overpotential to offset a high activation energy. The enzymes are immobilised on suitable electrodes.||
PFE allows us to examine enzymes as if they are electronic devices. The diagram compares the voltammetry of a reversible electrocatalyst (left trace) with that of an irreversible electrocatalyst (right trace). Electrochemistry introduces the overpotential requirement as a measure of enzyme efficiency.
We have demonstrated (a) the use of enzymes in novel fuel cells that can even produce electricity from low H2 levels in air, (b) co-immobilisation of hydrogenases with other enzymes on carbon particles to produce catalysts for coupling H2/H+ interconversion to useful reactions, (c) attachment of enzymes to semi-conductor nanoparticles to harness sunlight and convert water into H2 and CO2 into CO. All these investigations reveal how human lifestyles could be changed for the better by being able to design catalysts as proficient as enzymes – a point we refer to as ‘bio-inspired catalysis’. The major lesson for catalyst design is that enzymes have evolved to exploit the ‘outer shell’ – the groups that lie just outside the central catalytic centre. Every entity is positioned optimally, in both space and time, to perform its role. The outer shell is very difficult to design and synthesise in chemistry, but easy to modify in enzymes using genetic engineering methods.
Hydrogenases: metalloenzymes that oxidise and produce molecular H2
The aim here is to understand the basis of the exquisite catalytic activity of hydrogenases. These enzymes contain Fe coordinated to unusual ligands (CO, CN-) in two main classes known as [FeFe]- and [NiFe]- hydrogenases. Molecular evolution has resulted in these common metals attaining the superb catalytic activity of platinum, by optimising the arrangement of the inner and outer coordination shells. In our work, the role of the outer-coordination shell is investigated through genetic engineering (molecular biology).
We are investigating how certain hydrogenases (noting these are enzymes whose active sites are essentially O2-sensitive ‘organometallic’ compounds deeply buried and protected within the protein) are able to function in the presence of O2. The information obtained is important for developing strains of microorganisms that could be farmed to produce H2 from sunlight using photosynthesis. We have succeeded for the first time in systematically re-engineering the active site of two [NiFe]-hydrogenases from E.coli, known as Hyd-1 and Hyd-2. A conserved arginine that is suspended in a ‘canopy’ above the Ni and Fe atoms is particularly important for activity. An interesting possibility is that the strongly basic guanidine head group may assist in H2 cleavage by acting as the base in a ‘frustrated Lewis pair’ mechanism. We are examining the roles of other residues that make up the ‘canopy’ and surrounding region. We are also investigating the roles of the FeS clusters that perform as long-range electron relays within the enzyme – how they transfer and store electrons during the catalytic cycle.
The Electrochemical Leaf
The aim here is to establish new technology for the conversion of solar and electrical energy into high-value organic chemicals. We invented the ‘leaf’ in 2015, and it was patented in March 2016. The technology is based on the photosynthetic enzyme ferredoxin-NADP+ reductase (FNR) which contains a flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) cofactor. The role of FNR in the plant chloroplast is to convert photosynthetically derived electrons into a hydride entity that is stored on the nicotinamide cofactor known as NADPH and used to produce organic molecules from CO2, through the Calvin cycle.
By attaching FNR to an electrode, the electrochemistry of NADP+/NADPH becomes reversible and diffusional-controlled, making it possible to drive a vast number of regio- and stereo-specific organic reactions catalysed by the appropriate secondary enzymes. There are many features in developing this technology, which include engineering FNR to operate with NAD+/NADH, developing electrodes that have FNR and the secondary enzyme positioned close together to maximise efficiency, and the numerous opportunities for bespoke reactor design. We are also configuring the ‘leaf’ as a fuel cell to run on H2, and as a solar cell to run on sunlight.
Selected recent publications
Importance of the Active Site ‘Canopy’ Residues in an O2-tolerant [NiFe]-hydrogenase. E. J. Brooke, R. M. Evans, S. T. A. Islam, G. M. Roberts, S. A. M. Wehlin, S. B. Carr, S. E. V. Phillips and F. A. Armstrong. Biochemistry 56, 132-142 (2017). (link)
Electrochemical investigations of the mechanism of assembly of the active-Site H-cluster of [FeFe]-Hydrogenases. C. F. Megarity, J. Esselborn, S. V. Hexter, F. Wittkamp, U.-P. Apfel, T. Happe and F. A. Armstrong. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 138, 15227-15233 (2016).
Catalysis of solar hydrogen production by iron atoms on the surface of Fe-doped silicon carbide. Z. Wang and F. A. Armstrong. Catalysis Science and Technology, 6, 7038 - 7041 (2016).
Guiding Principles of Hydrogenase Catalysis Instigated and Clarified by Protein Film Electrochemistry. F. A. Armstrong, R. M. Evans, S. V. Hexter, B. J. Murphy, M. M. Roessler and P. Wulff. Acc. Chem. Res. 49, 884-892 (2016).
Mechanism of Hydrogen Activation by [NiFe]-hydrogenases R. M. Evans, E. J. Brooke, S. A. M. Wehlin, E. Nomerotskaia, F. Sargent, S. B. Carr, S. E. V. Phillips and F. A. Armstrong. Nature Chem. Biol. 12, 46-50 (2016).
How the Oxygen Tolerance of a [NiFe]-Hydrogenase depends on Quaternary Structure. P. Wulff, C. Thomas, F. Sargent and F. A. Armstrong. J. Biol. Inorg. Chem. 21, 121-134 (2016).
How formaldehyde inhibits hydrogen evolution by [FeFe]-hydrogenases: determination by 13C ENDOR of direct Fe-C coordination and order of electron and proton transfers. A. Bachmeier, J. Esselborn, S. V. Hexter, T. Kramer, K. Klein, T. Happe, J. E. McGrady, W. K. Myers and F. A. Armstrong. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 137, 5381-5389 (2015).
Discovery of dark pH-dependent H+ migration in a [NiFe]-hydrogenase and its mechanistic relevance: mobilizing the hydrido ligand of the Ni-C intermediate. B. J. Murphy, R. Hidalgo, M. M. Roessler, R. M. Evans, Philip A. Ash, W. K. Myers, K. A. Vincent and F. A. Armstrong. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 137, 8484-8489 (2015).
Solar-driven proton and carbon dioxide reduction to fuels - lessons from metalloenzymes A. Bachmeier and F.A. Armstrong, Current Opinion in Chemical Biology 25, 141-151 (2015).
Selective visible light-driven CO2 reduction on a p-type dye-sensitized NiO photocathode. A. Bachmeier, S. Hall, S. W. Ragsdale and F. A. Armstrong. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 136, 13518-13521 (2014).
How Oxygen reacts with Oxygen-tolerant Respiratory [NiFe]-Hydrogenases. P. Wulff, C. C. Day, F. Sargent and F. A. Armstrong. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.USA 111, 6606-6611 (2014).
Optimizing the Power of Enzyme-based Membrane-less Hydrogen Fuel Cells for Hydrogen-rich H2/air mixtures. L. Xu and F. A. Armstrong. Energy Environ. Science 6, 2166 - 2171 (2013).
Visible Light-driven CO2 reduction by Enzyme coupled CdS nanocrystals. Y. S. Chaudhary, T. W. Woolerton, C. S. Allen, J. H. Warner, E. Pierce, S. W. Ragsdale and F. A. Armstrong. Chem. Commun. 48, 58 - 60 (2012).
The Principles of Sustained Enzymatic Hydrogen Oxidation in the Presence of Oxygen - the Crucial Influence of High Potential Fe-S Clusters in the Electron Relay of [NiFe]-hydrogenases. R. M. Evans, A. Parkin, M. M. Roessler, B. J. Murphy, H. Adamson, M. J. Lukey, F. Sargent, A. Volbeda, J. C. Fontecilla-Camps and F. A. Armstrong. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 135, 2694-2707 (2013).
Electrocatalytic mechanism of Reversible Hydrogen cycling by Enzymes and Distinctions between the major classes of Hydrogenases. S. V. Hexter, F. Grey, T. Happe, V. Climent and F. A. Armstrong. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109, 11516-11521 (2012).
EPR spectroscopic studies of the Fe-S clusters in the O2-tolerant [NiFe]-hydrogenase Hyd-1 from E. coli, and characterization of the unique [4Fe-3S] cluster by HYSCORE. M. M. Roessler, R. M. Evans, R. A. Davies, J. Harmer, and F. A. Armstrong. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 134, 15581-15594 (2012).
Enzymes and bio-inspired Electrocatalysts in Solar Fuel Devices. T. W. Woolerton, S. Sheard, Y. S. Chaudhary and F. A. Armstrong. Energy Environ. Science 5, 7470 - 7490 (2012).
Reversibility and Efficiency in Electrocatalytic Energy Conversion and Lessons from Enzymes. F. A. Armstrong and J. Hirst. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108, 14049-14054 (2011).
Oxygen Tolerant [NiFe]-Hydrogenases: the Individual and Collective Importance of Supernumerary Cysteines at the Proximal Fe S Cluster. M. J. Lukey, M. M. Roessler, A. Parkin, R. M. Evans, R. A. Davies, O. Lenz, B. Friedrich, F. Sargent and F. A. Armstrong. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 133, 16881-16892 (2011).
Energy ... beyond oil. Edited by F. Armstrong and K. Blundell. Oxford University Press: Oxford (2007).
‘Inorganic Chemistry’ (Formally Shriver & Atkins) by M. T. Weller, T. L. Overton, J. P. Rourke, and F. A. Armstrong. Oxford University Press (2013) 6th edition.